Two reports released on Monday during the start of Banned Books Week present contrasting perspectives on book censorship in the United States. The American Library Association reported a decrease in book challenges in 2024 compared to previous years, attributing the decline to anti-censorship activism and legal victories against restrictive laws. However, PEN America documented a significant increase in book removals from school shelves in 2023-24, with over 10,000 books being pulled, particularly in Florida and Iowa where censorship laws have been passed.
The ALA’s report showed that while there has been a slight decrease in book challenges, censorship efforts targeting books by marginalized groups, particularly people of color and LGBTQ individuals, continue to have a real impact on young people’s access to information. The association attributed the decline in challenges to successful legal battles and activism, but noted that objections to certain titles persist as lawmakers in multiple states introduce legislation to censor library materials.
PEN America’s data on book bans highlight that restrictions on access to books, even temporary, are a threat to free speech and expression. The organization noted that a significant number of the banned books address issues related to race and LGBTQ topics. Banned Books Week, supported by various literary organizations, aims to raise awareness about censorship and promote the freedom to read.
In conclusion, while the ALA reports a decline in book challenges, PEN America highlights an increase in book removals, underscoring the continued importance of advocating for the freedom to access diverse perspectives and ideas in literature.
Photo credit
www.nbcnews.com
